Original text published by No es época para tontos.
Imagine a bank demanding six million euros, then acknowledging that one loan was transferred to an investment fund. The court rules for the bank; the Superior Court overturns it. The lower court rules again; the Superior Court overturns it again. Welcome to Andorra’s judicial ping-pong championship: the ball is worth millions.
The story begins in 2018. Vall Banc claims €5,735,225.29 from Josep-Maria Loan Fité under four credit agreements, excluding later interest. In September 2019, however, the bank acknowledges in a court filing that one credit had been securitised and assigned to an investment fund, while Vall Banc continued managing its collection. Collecting another party’s debt can be lawful. But who owned it, who had authority to sue, and who stood to benefit?
Pleyade 21 later seeks to replace Vall Banc as claimant. In May 2023, Andorra’s Court of First Instance, the Batllia, delivers a judgment substantially upholding the claim. On April 8, 2025, the Superior Court annuls that judgment and the procedural succession decision. The transfer needs proof, and the defence must be able to challenge it. Surely that is elementary.
Then comes September 2025. The Batllia panel, with Nadia Alís Cirera as reporting judge, considers Pleyade 21’s documents without granting the hearing it had itself ordered. On September 16 it recognises Pleyade’s procedural succession; on September 24 it rules on a withdrawal request; and on September 29 it issues another judgment. The earlier decisions are not yet final.
On October 9, 2026, the Superior Court intervenes once more. It declares the September 16 and 24 orders and the September 29 judgment null and void. Its finding is not about a misplaced comma: the defence suffered actual and effective procedural prejudice. Reconsideration appeals were dismissed months later without examination on the merits. The Superior Court explicitly says these violations do not themselves establish judicial bias. But two annulled judgments in one multimillion-euro case demand more than a shrug.
The question of ownership is still unresolved. Across the 2018 claim, the 2019 evidence, the succession application, the first appeal and the document submissions of 2025, Vall Banc and Pleyade 21 had repeated opportunities to clarify the chain of title. A subsequent certificate identifies three transferred assets whose references do not directly match the four loans claimed. Banking identifiers can change. Fine: produce a certified cross-reference. A bank demands documents to open an account; surely a claim for millions deserves at least as much paperwork.
Meanwhile, another question hangs over the case: the real estate investment fund. Financial records supplied for Vall Banc Fons Real Estate FI show a historical 89.34% decline in unit value. That is not evidence of theft or proof that 89.34% of its cash vanished. It demands audited accounts, inventories, assignment deeds and liquidation records. Who booked the credit, who could enforce it, and where would payments go? The manager and depositary are distinct; dissolving the manager does not prove the fund ended.
And where was the oversight? What did the Andorran Financial Authority verify? What do AREB’s records show about the transfer of assets after the BPA crisis? What should the Consell Superior de la Justícia examine after two annulments? The Government cannot tell judges how to decide cases, and the Co-Princes do not settle private debt disputes. Judicial independence, however, cannot be a synonym for silence or a substitute for institutional accountability.
There was press coverage of the latest annulment. But reporting a court ruling is not the same as following a contested credit through a bank’s restructuring, an investment fund and a corporate successor. Who has demanded the accounts, questioned the auditors and traced the money?
Andorra promotes itself internationally as a place of financial solidity and legal certainty. These claims ring hollow when a court has to send a multimillion-euro case back twice and a fundamental question about the chain of ownership remains disputed. Investors do not need reassuring seals. They need documents that withstand scrutiny.
Two judgments overturned. Four loans. An investment fund with extraordinary historical losses. No evidence here proves anyone stole the fund’s assets. But three questions cannot wait another decade: who owned each credit, who could lawfully collect it, and who is accountable for the denial of defence rights confirmed by the Superior Court?
In table tennis, the referee can order a point to be replayed. In justice, repeating a void judgment means repeating the cost. The ball can return to the table. Trust, without answers, cannot.