Texto original publicado por No es época para tontos.

Two arrests, contradictory records and missing evidence in the Josep Parramon case.

Andorra promises tranquillity. But public safety has a second meaning: protection from the state's own coercive power. How did a police dispute become two arrests and years of prosecution?

That question drives Andorra Justice Watch's examination of Josep Parramon Llavet's 1,136-page case file.

A PLANNED STREET ARREST

On 18 December 2021, officers P0415 and P0421 visited Parramon's home to deliver a court summons. A heated exchange followed. Their AXON body cameras reportedly recorded it, but police acknowledged a one-hour clock discrepancy. The original files and metadata are essential.

On 20 December, at 10:25 a.m., the same officers went looking for Parramon, found him and handcuffed him in the street. Their report notes no physical resistance.

The arrest was planned, not spontaneous. Article 27 of Andorra's Criminal Procedure Code permits warrantless arrest in defined circumstances. But why was custody necessary for a known, locatable citizen over a verbal dispute two days earlier? Why not summon him?

ALBERCA AND THE DUTY TO SUPERVISE

Alfons Alberca Sanvicens, the duty prosecutor, defended the arrest during habeas corpus proceedings (pages 45–47). Article 28 gives the prosecution service oversight of the appropriateness and duration of certain police detentions.

The dossier does not prove that Alberca ordered the arrest. It does document his defence of it. When was he notified? What instructions did he issue? What justified continued custody? The communication logs must be disclosed.

Judge Sergi Costa Gonçalves rejected habeas corpus and later advanced the criminal case. One discrepancy is striking: the police account records Parramon threatening to report officers for misconduct; a judicial decision refers to him calling them “prevaricators.” Announcing a legal complaint is not the same as making a direct criminal accusation.

Costa's reasoning also mentions Parramon's refusal to testify. Silence is a defence right, not evidence of guilt. Prosecutors later dropped the threats allegation from this episode. That demands an explanation.

THE SECOND ARREST: WHICH SUMMONS WAS VALID?

On 15 December 2021, judge Maria Àngels Moreno Aguirre asked police director Jordi Moreno Blázquez to serve a summons for 12 January 2022. Police paperwork records an attempted delivery and receipt details on 18 December. A subsequent judicial order says police notification failed, while referring to another notification by court staff.

Which notice was legally valid? Produce the originals, signatures and times.

Moreno ordered Parramon's arrest on 12 January under Article 102. Officer P0376 executed it at 8 a.m. on 18 January; commissioner Miquel Àngel Barbolla appears in communications with the judge. Parramon attended with his lawyer Emili Campos. The judge found no grounds for pretrial imprisonment under Article 103.

The two provisions differ. But did a court appearance truly require arrest?

MISSING AUDIO, ESCALATING PENALTIES

An earlier alleged phone incident, dated 4 December 2020, presents another evidentiary problem: a police report states that the original recording was unavailable after a server failure. When the accusation hinges on words, missing audio matters.

Prosecutors also sought nighttime detention, a fine and initially professional disqualification, while earlier convictions were invoked in relation to repeat offending. Each element requires scrutiny. Insult, criticism, threat and disobedience are legally distinct.

The dossier identifies a 245-day gap between recorded acts in 2026. Certain offences against honour carry a six-month limitation period, subject to interruption. A certified docket is needed to establish prescription.

WHO ANSWERS FOR THE DECISIONS?

The defence, including lawyers Emili Campos and Pere Cristòfol, has grounds to demand the complete AXON recordings, all original summonses, police instructions, prosecution call logs and a certified procedural chronology. The respective decisions of police, prosecutors, judges and the Tribunal de Corts must be examined individually.

These records raise serious questions about necessity, proportionality and due process. They do not, by themselves, prove a coordinated plot or criminal wrongdoing by any named official. Independent scrutiny is essential.

Andorra may be celebrated as one of the safest countries while retaining practices critics compare to those of a banana republic. Safety is not merely the absence of street crime. It is the certainty that state power has limits.

The central question is no longer what Parramon said on his doorstep. It is whether the authorities can justify what they did next. Those answers must be demanded before the damage becomes irreversible.

ANDORRA JUSTICE WATCH · informacions.ad