Texte original publié par Josep Guirao and Racheal B. · AJW — Andorra Justice Watch.
Who scrutinizes the judges who come to Andorra from neighbouring countries? The question is not whether Spanish and French professionals belong in the Principality's courts. Their appointment is explicitly contemplated by legal and international cooperation arrangements. The issue is whether their selection, previous judicial work, outside obligations, recusal decisions and disciplinary accountability can be examined with sufficient transparency. Tracing careers from Girona to Andorra reveals several magistrates involved in major financial proceedings before working, or applying to work, in the Andorran judiciary. Those career connections are documented; any suggestion of unlawful coordination would require separate evidence.
One trail leads to Info-Cobro, a finance and judicial-auction business associated with entrepreneur Jordi Cuxart Teres that entered insolvency proceedings in 2011. The business failure affected numerous investors and triggered civil, commercial and criminal proceedings. Describing the entire affair as having been quietly dismissed would blur important distinctions. Different courts examined different transactions and allegations. An investigation worthy of the name must establish each case number, the judge responsible, the decision made and the outcome of appeals, including both convictions and any dismissals supported by actual court orders.
Hugo Novales Bilbao joined Andorra's Tribunal de Corts as a substitute magistrate on September 9, 2026. Previously, he had worked at Girona Commercial Court No. 1. In Info-Cobro insolvency proceeding 394/2011, he was involved in the liquidation and, on July 16, 2015, issued a judgment finding the insolvency culpable and imposing a 15-year disqualification on the company administrator. That ruling rules out the blanket assertion that Novales simply closed the insolvency case without consequences. Whether he dismissed separate complaints concerning alleged corruption is a different, still unverified question requiring the relevant order, date and case reference.
The criminal record is equally important. In judgment 899/2022, dated November 16, 2022, Spain's Supreme Court upheld a conviction for continued aggravated fraud in conjunction with falsification of accounting records in proceedings against Info-Cobro's administrator. That conviction does not resolve every allegation made by investors or explain the fate of every connected investigation. But it does mean that the wider scandal cannot accurately be described as an affair in which nobody was held criminally accountable. The remaining journalistic task is to map the other proceedings, identify how they concluded, and avoid treating unproven accusations as findings of fact.
Carles Cruz Moratones offers a direct documentary connection between that Girona insolvency case and Andorra's courts. He sat on the First Section of the Girona Provincial Court of Appeal, which decided appeals involving Info-Cobro, including judgments 164/2014, 191/2014 and 192/2014. Those decisions address insolvency administration, disputed claims and the recovery of assets. Cruz subsequently served in the Civil Chamber of Andorra's Superior Court of Justice. Two judges who dealt with legal issues arising from the same large insolvency, at different levels of the Spanish judicial system, later held judicial responsibilities in Andorra. That is a relevant professional link, not proof of improper collaboration.
Fernando Lacaba Sánchez, formerly president of Girona's Provincial Court, belongs in this investigation for a different reason. In 2017 he applied for a position on the Andorran Superior Court. Elsa Puig Muñoz ultimately obtained the position; there is no basis for presenting Lacaba as having served in Andorra through that selection. Years earlier, press reports had referred to a complaint alleging economic links with figures around Info-Cobro. Those reports are allegations, not judicial findings. A responsible investigation must obtain the original complaint, determine whether formal proceedings followed, establish their final outcome and examine the published selection criteria from 2017.
The wider Girona–Andorra network includes Fátima Ramírez Souto, who worked in Girona's provincial judiciary before serving on Andorra's Criminal Chamber, and Víctor Correas Sitjes, another former Girona judicial officer later appointed as a substitute judge in the Principality. Both were named in the announced panel reviewing an appeal in the BPA case in 2026. Joan Manel Abril Campoy, likewise associated with the Girona Provincial Court, went on to serve on Andorra's Constitutional Court. These career paths are lawful in principle, but make the availability of appointment records, authorization decisions, case-allocation rules and mechanisms for challenging impartiality especially important.
September 2026 provides a striking chronology that must not be exaggerated. Novales took up his Andorran duties on September 9. On September 30, Andorra's General Council officially published a bill accompanying the 2027 budget, including measures affecting housing and the extension of rights of first refusal and repurchase over certain properties arising from bankruptcy or insolvency. The government led by Demòcrates per Andorra presented expanded acquisition powers as a way of increasing housing availability. Related statutory powers predated Novales's arrival. No evidence reviewed establishes that he drafted, promoted or influenced the bill. Temporal proximity alone cannot establish causation.
The property proposal nevertheless raises legitimate and concrete questions. How will independent valuations be secured? How will creditors' rights be protected? What safeguards will apply if a property is acquired following an unsuccessful auction, including through a direct award? Will transaction values and decision criteria be reported in a form that allows public audit? The policy goal of increasing available housing deserves examination on its merits. Transparent procedures are essential precisely when a measure serves an important public purpose and concerns assets whose disposal may otherwise be contested.
Andorra has already faced a judicial controversy over a judge's participation in a property auction. In its June 13, 2022 judgment on constitutional appeal 2022-24-RE, the Constitutional Court reviewed the handling of a disciplinary matter concerning judge Xavier Colom Pich, who had participated in an auction connected to enforcement proceedings in which he was said to have been involved. The Constitutional Court quashed earlier rulings and required a fresh, reasoned judicial decision on whether proceedings concerning possible liability should be opened. It did not find the judge guilty. The ruling did, however, identify a procedural failure of constitutional significance. Joan Manel Abril Campoy was among the judges who signed it.
Another controversy concerns former constitutional judge Josep Delfí Guàrdia Canela and his earlier membership of the board of CriteriaCaixa, a group with property interests in Andorra. A complaint alleging incompatibility became public in July 2025. The result is an essential part of the story: in October 2025, Andorra's Constitutional Court rejected the complaint, finding no evidence of incompatibility. It also noted the complainant's failure to appear to confirm the allegations and, according to the published account of the decision, that Guàrdia had left Criteria before his constitutional appointment and had not taken part in cases concerning the company. Reporting only the accusation and omitting this ruling would be misleading.
Looking north reveals the French dimension. Vincent Anière's judicial career can be followed through French official records showing assignments in Évreux, Foix and Perpignan, including investigating-judge and vice-presidential duties. In February 2019, Andorra appointed him president of the Civil Chamber of its Superior Court. To establish whether any assignments overlapped, or whether overlapping responsibilities were compatible, investigators must compare precise French and Andorran appointment decisions and individual approvals. Franco-Andorran administrative cooperation provides mechanisms for secondment and professional mobility; a legal framework exists, but its individual application should still be transparent.
The relationship extends back well before the contemporary constitution. Carles Obiols i Taberner, a former president of the Girona Provincial Court, held judicial responsibilities in pre-1993 Andorra. Antoni Sabater i Tomàs, whose judicial career also included Girona, served as a delegated appellate judge and later as Andorra's prosecutor general. The circulation of judicial professionals across this border is therefore a longstanding institutional practice rather than a one-off development. Its history makes a comprehensive public record of appointments, terms of office, relevant financial arrangements and disciplinary jurisdictions especially valuable.
Andorra Justice Watch does not claim that judges with shared professional backgrounds constitute a secret network or that the 2027 housing bill was designed around any particular magistrate. Its demand is for verifiable records. The full Info-Cobro case history should be mapped; any dismissal allegedly signed by Novales should be identified; the outcome of allegations concerning Lacaba should be established from primary documents; and the safeguards governing cross-border appointments should be made understandable to the public. Changes to auction and acquisition rules deserve equally exact scrutiny. Judicial independence is protected by reasoned decisions, open procedures and accountability—not by shielding institutions from legitimate questions.
KEY DOCUMENTS: Girona Provincial Court, judgment 192/2014: https://www.iberley.es/jurisprudencia/sentencia-civil-n-192-2014-ap-girona-sec-1-rec-551-2013-13-06-2014-14647401 ; Andorra Constitutional Court, case 2022-24-RE: https://bopa.mca.ad/doctrina?c=TS20220613_17_57_50&f=tc ; 2027 budget-related legislative procedure: https://seu.consellgeneral.ad/normativaMilloradaAnunciPublic/categories?tipusId=11 ; Vincent Anière appointment: https://ad.vlex.com/vid/acord-data-13-febrer-787542693 ; Guàrdia Canela ruling: https://cadenaser.com/andorra/2025/10/29/el-tribunal-constitucional-desestima-la-denuncia-contra-josep-guardia-canela-per-incompatibilitats-radio-ser-principat-d-andorra/ .
