Original text published by No es época para tontos.

If an ordinary citizen breaks the law, consequences follow. If a lawyer commits malpractice, liability may follow. But when a judge makes a grave error that destroys a business, a home or years of someone’s life, who is held accountable? Who judges the judges?

This investigation by Andorra Justice Watch examines a paradox at the heart of modern justice: the people entrusted with enforcing the law enjoy safeguards so formidable that the victims of serious judicial failures may struggle to obtain either compensation or accountability.

The distinction is crucial. An overturned judgment is not proof of misconduct. Courts must be free to interpret disputed laws without fearing personal retaliation. But what happens when a judge ignores a decisive document, disregards an elementary procedural guarantee or repeatedly makes the same fundamental error? Where does legitimate independence end—and inexcusable ignorance begin?

A 2010 study by legal scholar Francisco Oliva Blázquez examined how Spanish courts historically approached judges’ civil liability. The audio traces seven formidable hurdles: demonstrating a manifest breach of law, exceptional negligence, violation of a sufficiently clear rule, the circumstances in which the judge worked, quantifiable damage, exhaustion of appeals and a direct causal connection.

The practical result, the investigation argues, was a remedy that existed more convincingly on paper than in real life. Spain then changed its system. Organic Law 7/2015 abolished direct civil actions against judges for conduct in their judicial functions, directing claims for judicial error or abnormal administration of justice toward the State. The public purse can pay for harm; recourse against a judge is a separate matter.

Andorra has its own legal framework. Article 10 of its Qualified Law on Justice provides a route for State compensation, subject to demanding conditions—including a three-month period for bringing the relevant action. Article 76 addresses judges’ personal civil liability for intentional harm. And Article 83(d), amended in 2022, classifies “inexcusable ignorance of laws and procedures” as a very serious disciplinary offence.

Three possible routes, three very different questions: Can the victim prove compensable damage in time? Can intentional wrongdoing be established? Will the judicial governing body investigate a potentially grave professional failure? A disciplinary sanction does not rebuild a ruined business; financial compensation does not necessarily establish individual misconduct.

The inquiry also examines judicial cooperation across the Spanish–Andorran border. Public institutional records cited in the audio document the 2019 authorisation for magistrate Carles Cruz Moratones, then serving at Girona’s Provincial Court, to continue combining that post with duties in Andorra’s Civil Chamber of the High Court. A related renewal request appears on a 2024 agenda.

This dual role is lawful. It is not evidence of corruption, incompetence or bias. The legitimate investigative questions concern oversight: Who checks combined workloads? How are cross-border conflicts of interest identified? What information can litigants obtain when they have reason to question a judge’s independence?

Imagine winning an appeal only to see your case sent back, delayed and contested again. Each annulment may demonstrate that appellate safeguards work. But for a citizen paying years of legal fees while a company collapses, procedural correction can come too late. An annulment alone cannot establish disciplinary guilt; repeated breakdowns nevertheless deserve rigorous examination.

Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights protects the right to a fair hearing within a reasonable time before an independent and impartial tribunal. Strasbourg distinguishes actual personal bias from objective guarantees capable of dispelling legitimate doubts. Working in two countries is not automatically a violation. The point is whether safeguards are effective, credible and open to scrutiny.

So where are the meaningful statistics on disciplinary complaints, investigations and sanctions? Where is the auditable evidence that these protections work? And if public accountability is difficult for human judges, what happens when an overworked magistrate signs a flawed judgment prepared with artificial intelligence?

Andorra does not need judges obedient to politicians, wealthy interests or public outrage. It needs independent judges accountable to the law. A justice system that demands answers from everyone must be prepared to answer for itself.

Andorra Justice Watch (AJW) #Andorra #AndorraJusticeWatch #JudicialAccountability #HumanRights #Justice

The player loads when you select “Watch video”.Open on YouTube