Original text published by No es época para tontos.

What happens when a defence lawyer faces criminal investigation over words written for a client? In Andorra, the question reaches beyond one courtroom to a promise made in 1993: power would answer to law, and citizens could challenge it without fear.

THE MAN WHO LOOKED BEYOND THE MOUNTAINS

Roger Rossell Vilaginés helped bring Andorra's democratic shortcomings to Europe's attention. His story began in culture. Associated with the Casa d'Andorra in Paris, he directed Posobra, a Catalan-language journal published in six issues in 1972–1973, including an interview with French thinker Michel de Certeau.

In 1987, Rossell, Simó Duró and Jordi Llovera campaigned through the Grup Andorrà Europa, alerting European representatives to shortcomings in political rights. A Council of Europe delegation visited in 1989; in May 1990, its Parliamentary Assembly passed Resolution 946, calling for a written constitution and reforms. Andorrans approved their Constitution on 14 March 1993.

Rossell did not draft the Constitution, nor did three activists achieve reform alone. They did help carry Andorra's democratic demands abroad.

A CONSTITUTION—AND AN UNFINISHED ARGUMENT

The Constitution recognized popular sovereignty but retained the co-princes: France's president and the bishop of Urgell. Rossell questioned the bishop's role and signed petitions concerning sovereignty and judicial guarantees, including demands linked to Article 91.1 of the new Constitution. For him, reform had to change institutions, not merely their language.

On 15 March 1993, Rossell wrote in El País of professional obstacles and pressure on his family tied to activism. Judge Xavier Jordana rejected political motives for judicial action. The allegations are documented; a campaign of persecution is not proven by them.

THE CASE THAT OUTLIVED A GENERATION

That June, a separate inheritance dispute began: case 2-076/93. Rossell's expert valued the estate's real property at €6,082,500; he claimed an inheritance share. Rulings in 2006 and 2008 fixed the sum payable at €4,000. The gap is startling. But an estate valuation is not a court-recognized entitlement; the judgments must explain the result.

In 2025, Rossell sought review and questioned judicial impartiality, asking for the recusal of Pere Pastor Vilanova and Joan Manel Abril Campoy. On 17 November, the Constitutional Court rejected the recusals and declared his appeal inadmissible (2025-78-RE). Disagreement with a judgment does not itself prove bias.

THEN THE LAWYER BECAME THE STORY

Rossell's lawyer, Emili Campos, criticized aspects of the proceedings in written submissions. According to Campos's complaint, a letter from the Constitutional Court president on 2 December 2025 flagged language in those filings. Criminal proceedings followed over potentially defamatory statements. Campos was summoned as a suspect in 2026. On 30 September, he filed a complaint against senior judicial and prosecutorial officials, alleging violations of fundamental rights.

The investigation does not establish Campos's guilt; his complaint does not establish wrongdoing by officials. But what happens to effective defence when criticism in court triggers criminal scrutiny?

THE FREEDOM TO DEFEND

Articles 6 and 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights protect fair hearings and freedom of expression. In Morice v. France, Strasbourg addressed lawyers' freedom to criticize justice. The protection is significant, not unlimited: facts, context and proportionality matter.

Andorra signed the Council of Europe's lawyer-protection convention (CETS 226) in May 2025 but had not ratified it as of November 2026. Signing is not ratification. The underlying principle remains vital: defence without improper pressure. The wider danger is the chilling effect: if one lawyer fears prosecution for a forceful argument, others may begin to censor themselves before a judge ever speaks.

THE QUESTION NO CONSTITUTION CAN AVOID

Fifty-four years separate Posobra's first issue from 2026. That is a historical span, not Rossell's age. The record does not prove a 33-year conspiracy. It does show a reform campaign, allegations of intimidation, prolonged litigation and criminal scrutiny of a lawyer's words. Rossell's continued role in Paneuropa Andorra adds another layer: the same citizen engaged in European civic networks remained entangled in domestic legal battles.

These events demand evidence, scrutiny and answers, not a predetermined verdict. Every democracy faces the same question: is a constitution measured by its promises, or by how it protects those who insist they be kept?

ANDORRA JUSTICE WATCH | https://informacions.ad #RogerRossell #EmiliCampos #Andorra #HumanRights #RuleOfLaw

The player loads when you select “Watch video”.Open on YouTube